Wireframe vs mockup vs prototype for the best design flow

29 Jan 2019

Before any line of code is written, there is the pre-development design phase every project usually goes through. That’s when wireframes, mockups, and prototypes are created.

Mockup vs prototype vs wireframe is a subject that needs clarity, as it is seen differently by designers and clients.

There’s a common misconception that you can easily craft your design omitting a stage or two. We’ve created tens of thousands of designs and want to present our vision of the wireframe vs mockup vs prototype subject. So let’s elaborate on what wireframes, mockups, and prototypes mean and how they make design pixel perfect.

wireframes_vs_mockups_vs_prototypes_for_the_best_design_flow_image_1.png.930x0_q90

Source: tapptitude.com

What is a wireframe?

Simply put, a wireframe is a draft or a sketch by a designer. The purpose of wireframes is to show the structure of an application with basic elements and content placement. This structure helps developers see the functional side of the app. Designers can bring order to scattered ideas and present them schematically. Wireframes serve as a foundation for a website or app.

What does a wireframe consist of?

Wireframes show the logic of a website or app. They present the product at its inception stage and consist of:

boxes or circles
lines
text

Below, you can see a screenshot of clickable wireframes we created for one of our clients. The wireframes are for an eLearning website that helps users pass a driver’s license test in California. We used Axure, a special design tool, to create wireframes.

wireframes_vs_mockups_vs_prototypes_for_the_best_design_flow_image_2.png.930x0_q90

You can also check out these interactive wireframes for a social app we created.

wireframes_vs_mockups_vs_prototypes_for_the_best_design_flow_image_3.png.600x0_q90

When to use wireframe architecture

You can use wireframes when you want to:

discuss ideas or concepts
show the structure of pages
see how related pages work together
see how information will be presented on individual screens
mimic interface behavior
visualize the general layout of a website or app
prepare a detailed project requirements document
test usability within your team to adjust your product

What is a mockup design?

The next step after wireframing is creating a mockup. A mockup transforms the schematic layout into a colorful, static representation of the future product. With mockups, you can see shapes, fonts, and the color palette. Sometimes, you can even see content instead of dummy text. The main difference between wireframes and mockups is that mockup user flow doesn’t skip details; on the contrary, they’re all about details, giving the feel of an actual app and showing how elements go together.

What are the components of a mockup?

With a mockup, you shape the way your app will look like. A mockup may include:

buttons
text bars
content layout
colors and graphics
typography
spacing around components
navigation graphics
other visual parts

Here’s a collection of website mockup examples we created for one of our projects. We experimented with layouts and colors in Sketch, a popular piece of website mockup software, until our client approved the designs.

wireframes_vs_mockups_vs_prototypes_for_the_best_design_flow_image_4.png.930x0_q90

Source: dribbble.com by Sergey Shevchenko

When to use mockups

You can use an architecture mockup when you want to:

decide on the product’s color scheme, visual style, and typography
experiment with the look of the product
present the user interface to stakeholders and potential users
be confident about your design
decide on your brand identity

What is a prototype?

A prototype is a high-fidelity interactive manifestation of the final product. Even though prototypes aren’t put into code yet, they look like actual applications. The main difference between mockup vs prototype is that users can easily interact with prototypes and test the user flow.

What are the main features of prototypes?

A prototype should be as similar to the final product as possible in order to model the user experience. Therefore, a prototype should:

connect all elements in an interactive flow
be a basis for new insights
encourage further development
be a testing and learning tool

Here’s an example of a prototype for an eCommerce website we created. Below, you can see how a user can scroll through items, choose a dress they like, view details, and place an order.

redress_dribbble_preview_1.gif.600x0_q90

Source: Dribbble.com by Yvette Mosiichuk

When to use prototyping

You can use prototypes when you want to:

show more than just product visuals
try your product’s capabilities before going live
gather valuable feedback on usability from users and stakeholders
perform A/B testing

After discussing the difference between prototype vs mockup vs wireframe, let’s see how they’re connected.

How do wireframes, mockups, and prototypes orchestrate the design process?

All three stages ― creating a wireframe, prototype, and mockup ― should find a place in your design process. Don’t underestimate the importance of every prototype, wireframe, and mockup, since they’re your foundation to build on.

When you come to a development team, you have an app idea in mind. But it’s your idea, in your mind. You need to convey this idea to your developers and designers. The first thing they should do once you tell them about your product is turn your idea into wireframes ― a language that helps designers translate your idea into designs and lets developers understand the app’s architecture and the best coding solutions.

Your application should acquire structure over time and gradually translate into a mockup. At this stage, you get to finalize your design and see how structural elements turn into buttons, graphics, and content layouts. But the work isn’t done yet.

Ultimately, this leads to prototyping. With a prototype, you get to walk in your users’ shoes. You get to feel what it’s like to interact with your product.

Design process at Globaldev

At Globaldev, designers pay special attention to clickable wireframes, interactive mockup samples, and prototypes. Over the years, we’ve come up with a plan of action that lets our clients win over the development time and resources and build meaningful products for users. We’ve learned by experience that successful design can only be achieved if you’re willing to go the whole way from wireframes to mockups to prototypes without skipping anything. This leads to an optimal app design that doesn’t require costly rework down the road.

To begin, we create wireframes that let us understand the structure, user flow, and core interactions in the website or app. Because we link the pages and screens, our clients get a visual and functional representation of their product at an early stage.

We usually hold demo meetings where we show the flow to our clients. We also share links to wireframes so our clients can test them on their own. This means both we and our client can follow the user journey. What’s more, this keeps us from getting lost among all the pages and screens later, during development.

Once our client approves the wireframes, we focus on mockups, which represent the UI part of the project. Building mockups is the stage where our designers give the structure a pretty face. The detailed structure of wireframes makes the work of our UI designers easy and helps our clients save time and resources.

Again, we want to be sure that our clients like our design solutions. When clients tell us we’re good to go, we create high-fidelity prototypes using Sketch UX prototyping software. These prototypes closely resemble the final product. Clients can interact with their website or app via a link in Invision and can even perform testing to understand how effective the product is.

Below is a table that highlights the essence of each method in the design process.

Wireframes vs mockups vs prototypes: Comparison table

wireframes_vs_mockups_vs_prototypes.png.930x0_q90

By building your design from wireframes to mockups to a prototype, you save money and time. It’s easier to change the logic and structure at the wireframing stage than at the prototyping stage. If you make changes later on, they will affect your design, code, or even business logic.

Push your design process to the forefront

If you’re creating a project from scratch, there’s no way you can skip design. Be on the safe side and go with wireframes, mockups, and prototypes. Your risk of getting things wrong will be lower and your chance of developing a high-quality product will rise.

We’re in the business of saving our clients’ time and money. We speak through well-designed consistent visuals and if you need a team to design and build your product, contact us!